A Cottage Collection

Seasonal Hours
Request A Quote

Vinyl vs. Laminate Flooring What’s Better?

A Cottage Collection Blog / By

The age-old question vinyl vs. laminate flooring and what is better, should you confuse vinyl flooring, especially vinyl plank, with laminate floors, you may have difficulty deciding which to purchase and set up. This is not your fault: manufacturers alike promote both as barely distinguishable durable, budget-friendly, do-it-yourself goods.

And that is where the similarities end.

Materials, depth, comfort level, and resistance to moisture are somewhat distinct. Base materials are at the core of the differences.

Begin using two simplifications:

Vinyl Flooring: 100% vinyl.

This Way: Superior resistance to moisture. You can submerge vinyl flooring in water for days, with no ill effect. Characteristics: Forget the ugly vinyl tiles of yesteryear. Plank shapes that are long and narrow, mimicking actual wood boards; “click” joinery, allowing adjoining planks to snap together; and improved embossing methods, vinyl flooring is gaining popularity once more.

Laminate Flooring: 99% wood product.

Won’t be resistant to water in the event of flooding, such as dishwasher overflow.

Features: Laminate flooring gained its foothold in the contemporary home–particularly kitchens–for one reason: it was the very first truly wood-look flooring that homeowners could install by themselves.

When Context Is a Consideration

Winner: Vinyl floors in baths, laminate floors everywhere else. Details under: Full Bathrooms: pick vinyl floors since it matches laminate in cost, looks, and DIY-friendly installation. But the true deciding factor is moisture. Vinyl floors beat laminate in its own performance in moist areas. In better homes where you would not expect to find vinyl flooring, exceptions are designed for baths. It’s understood that in these areas, water-shedding coverings like vinyl floors or ceramic tile is going to be utilized. The rest of the Rooms: laminate flooring supplies better looks and greater relaxation. Kitchen and Powder Rooms: Kitchens and guest bathrooms (i.e., powder rooms that have no bathing facilities), you do not expect water to pool on the ground. However, some crucial areas, like around the sink and dishwasher, can experience sufficient water to induce laminate to swell over time.

Vinyl vs. Laminate Flooring What’s Better? Ease of Setup

Winner: Comparable

Sheet vinyl comes in massive rolls and is hard for homeowners to put in as it’s so laborious and therefore difficult to form around obstacles. However, that installs sheet vinyl? Rather, many homeowners are currently purchasing and installing vinyl plank floors–simpler to put in much than square tile-sized vinyl since you have fewer bits to put.

Thickness

Winner: N/A

Ranging from 1.5 mm to 5 mm, vinyl floors is thinner than laminate’s 6 mm to 12 mm. However, this is the character of the two products. Laminate flooring will always be thicker by virtue of its own pressed-board wood center. Laminate necessitates foam moisture underlayment, although this is affordable and can be rolled out and taped together immediately (a few laminate includes the underlayment pre-attached to the trunk). Laminate must be cut with a hand saw, circular saw table saw fitted using an ultra-fine blade or a conventional blade installed backward.

Looks and Resale Value

Winner: Laminate flooring

Previously anathema to a fantastic house sale, vinyl flooring’s prestige has been creeping upward recently, particularly with the introduction of luxury vinyl floors (LVF). Still, as mentioned earlier, buyers may anticipate–or explanation–vinyl floors in the toilet but will throw a critical eye on your living room floored with vinyl, even nice vinyl plank.

Resistance To Moisture

Winner: Vinyl Floors

It’s not possible to conquer vinyl floors in the region of moisture resistance.

Sheet vinyl flooring is 100% resistant to moisture, even standing water since it could have as few as zero stitches. Therefore, vinyl can be installed in almost any room of the home. Vinyl is one of those few kinds of floors which you may call genuinely water-proof, not simply water-resistant.

Comfort

Winner: Laminate flooring

Vinyl floors, if installed right on a subfloor or concrete, is cold and hard.

Because laminate is thicker than vinyl and incorporates timber material, it’s easier to walk on and warmer to the touch than vinyl. Introducing foam underlayment adds even more comfort to laminate.

Recycled Value

Winner: Comparable

Previously, vinyl flooring has been the “poor boy,” earning standing among the very “green” floors products. But now, flooring manufacturers today produce vinyl flooring which accomplishes a LEED charge EQ4.3 to get Low-Emitting Material.

Laminate flooring uses wood material. Manufacturers produce a laminate that qualifies for LEED MR4